Vox Indie is dedicated to exploring issues surrounding online copyright and content creation. As a 33-year indie film and journalism veteran, I’ll share my perspectives on piracy and the damage done to creators worldwide. My hope is to share ideas about possible solutions and to foster a greater appreciation and understanding of creators’ rights in our evolving digital landscape.
Berkeley Law's dubious study on copyright notice and takedown faces more scrutiny
Last month--a day before deadline for public comments on the U.S. Copyright Office's study on the impact and effectiveness of the safe harbor provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (“DMCA”), section 512--UC-Berkeley School of Law and the American Assembly (via the Google-funded Takedown Project) released a study purporting to give a "broad picture of how section 512 notice and takedown works on the ground." A day after its release I wrote quick post highlighting some initial concerns with the study, but hadn't had time to fully digest the entire 160 page report. Now, nearly a month later, others have taken the time to more carefully look at the study and uncover its (many) dubious findings. Kevin Madigan & Devlin Hartline scholars at the Center for the Protection of Intellectual Property (CPIP) have published a detailed response to study, "Separating Fact from Fiction in the Notice and Takedown Debate," and note:
The study reads more like propaganda than robust empiricism. It should be taken for what it is: A policy piece masquerading as an independent study.
MORE FROM VOX INDIE
- Ad Sponsored Piracy
- Social Media
Google could learn a thing or two from VIMEO about how to run an efficient DMCA takedown systemLove it or hate it, for now the DMCA (Digital Millennium Copyright Act) is the law of the land when it comes to safeguarding creative content online. The law, passed nearly 20 years ago, is woefully outdated, but for now, it's the only tool creators have to protect their work from online thieves. Unfortunately, not every company in the business of "user generated content" approaches DMCA compliance the same way. Google, a company that makes billions each year in ad revenues generated via trafficking in dubious content, has set up a takedown system that ensures the sending of a DMCA takedown notice is an onerous and inefficient task. After all, the harder Google makes it, the more discouraged creators will become, and the more money continues to flow into its coffers...
Richard Gere's new movie "Arbitrage" was released this week to positive reviews and healthy box office returns. According to Variety, "Arbitrage ...is banking on...